Skip to Main Content
Penelope logo topPenelope logo scroll
  • (212)-481-3800
  • info@penelopenyc.com
  • 159 Lexington Ave , New York
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Order
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs
  • Gift Cards
  • Twitter pageFacebook pageInstagram pageYelp page
Penelope logo topPenelope logo scroll
  • Twitter pageFacebook pageInstagram pageYelp page
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Order
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs
  • Gift Cards

Our Menu

Main Menu

*Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness •Served until 4:00 PM

Breakfast

Steel Cut Irish Oatmeal

$9.50
Sliced banana, golden raisins, cinnamon & brown sugar.
Avocado Toast AF* photo

Avocado Toast AF*

$18.00
Sourdough toast, goat cheese, grape tomatoes, quinoa, pickled red onion, sunflower seeds, poached organic egg • Add Smoked Salmon +$5.50

Penny Egg Sammy

$10.50
Scrambled eggs with cheddar cheese & pesto on a fresh baked Croissant or Toasted Brioche Bun • Add Applewood Smoked Bacon +$3.00

Farm Stand Eggs Any Style

$15.50
Three farm fresh eggs any way you like ‘em • Applewood Smoked Bacon or Chicken Apple Sausage • Served with sourdough toast & savory home fries

Farmer’s Green Market Omelette

$16.50
Choice of three: Mushrooms, Asparagus, Tomatoes, Red Peppers, Spinach, Onion, Bacon, or Cheese (Cheddar, Swiss, Goat, Feta or Blue). Served with sourdough toast & savory home fries.
Nutella French Toast photo

Nutella French Toast

$18.50
Brioche French toast with warm chocolate hazelnut drizzle served with fresh seasonal berries & Vermont maple syrup.

Greener than Green Bowl

$16.50
Two farm stand eggs any style with power greens, asparagus, cucumber, French beans, English peas, roasted butternut squash, avocado & red quinoa. Served with sourdough toast • Add Applewood Smoked Bacon or Chicken Apple Sausage +$3.00
Our Signature Blueberry Pancakes photo

Our Signature Blueberry Pancakes

$19.00
Fluffy buttermilk pillows served with fresh blueberry compote and Vermont maple syrup • Add Applewood Bacon or Chicken Apple Sausage +$3.00
Penelope’s Hangover Bowl photo

Penelope’s Hangover Bowl

$18.50
Pastrami hash with red potato, sweet potato, red pepper, caramelized onion, and pickled mustard seed. Topped with two poached eggs, frisse & savory hollandaise.

Entrées

Penelope’s Blue Ribbon Chicken Pot Pie

$20.00
Savory buttermilk crust, Dutch style.
Gulf Shrimp, Turkey & Cajun Andouille Gumbo photo

Gulf Shrimp, Turkey & Cajun Andouille Gumbo

$19.50
Slow-cooked with dirty rice.
Pan Seared Faroe Island Salmon photo

Pan Seared Faroe Island Salmon

$23.50
Grilled asparagus & artichoke hearts with a Meyer lemon emulsion.

Olde English Fish N’ Chips

$22.00
Beer battered fresh cod with house-made tartar sauce.
Our Mindful Steak Frites photo

Our Mindful Steak Frites

$34.00
Pasture grazed New York strip with house-cut French fries.

Press Start

Warm Buttermilk Biscuits

$6.00
Fresh berry preserves.

Our Morning Glory Bowl

$10.00
Melon & berries, yogurt & granola.

Penelope’s Faves

Very Veggie Chili photo

Very Veggie Chili

$14.50
Smoky three bean, seasonal squash, caramelized onion, tomato, avocado, cheddar, pico de gallo, with corn chips.
Mac & 4 Cheese photo

Mac & 4 Cheese

$15.50
Gruyere, cheddar, fontina, Pecorino Romano.
Maria’s Chicken Meatballs photo

Maria’s Chicken Meatballs

$14.50/3
Blended with arugula, golden raisins, basil & parmigiano.

Burgers & Sammys

House-Cut Fries or Simple Salad

French Onion Soup Burger photo

French Onion Soup Burger

$18.00
Double-patty with sweet melted onion & gruyere.

Bugsy’s Veggie Burger

$17.50
House-made with fresh summer veggies & grains, with a smoky jalapeno pineapple glaze.
100% Grass-Fed Wagyu Burger photo

100% Grass-Fed Wagyu Burger

$19.00
Lettuce, tomato, shaved red onion & pickle • Add Cheese +$2.00 | Add Bacon +$3.00

K-Town Crispy Chicken Sammy

$17.50
Sweet & sour kimchi slaw with our special sauce.

BBLT

$16.50
Double bacon, arugula & tomato with a savory mayo on toasted sourdough • Add Avocado +$2.00 | Add Chicken Breast +$4.00

Croque “Madame Penelope”

$18.50
Shaved ham, gruyere, fines herbes, over easy organic egg.
Absolute Best Damn Lobster Roll photo

Absolute Best Damn Lobster Roll

$28.50
Touch of savory mayo, celery, lemon zest, sea salt on a warm lightly buttered brioche roll.

Signature Bowls

Penny Cobb photo

Penny Cobb

$18.50
Power greens, chicken breast, bacon, asparagus, grape tomato, hard-boiled egg, pickled red onion, avocado & Danish blue.
Roasted Cauliflower & Red Quinoa photo

Roasted Cauliflower & Red Quinoa

$17.00
Zante currants, toasted hazelnuts & turmeric/curry yogurt drizzle.

Baby Arugula & Luna Sweet Tomato

$16.50
Fresh buffalo mozzarella & local lemon basil • Add Chicken Breast +$4.00 | Add Chicken Meatballs +$4.00

Our Farmer’s Harvest Veggie & Grain

$16.50
Power greens, local pear, roasted butternut squash, ruby beets, pickled grapes, goat cheese, quinoa, spiced walnuts • Add Chicken Breast +$4.00
South Beach Samba photo

South Beach Samba

$20.50
Jumbo shrimp and seared yellowfin tuna with power greens, hearts of palm, avocado, grape tomato, and smoky red pepper.

Pastas

Butternut Squash Ravioli & Crumbled Sage photo

Butternut Squash Ravioli & Crumbled Sage

$19.50
Danish blue, dried cranberry, toasted walnuts with brown butter.
Linguine & Jumbo Shrimp photo

Linguine & Jumbo Shrimp

$22.50
Artichoke or Basil tapenade, pistachios, with sun-dried tomato oil.
Rigatoni Bolognese photo

Rigatoni Bolognese

$20.00
Old-world Italian ragu of beef, pork & veal.

Desserts

Crème Brulee Cheesecake

$8.50
Fresh seasonal berry compote.

Old-School Red Velvet Cake

$8.50
A la mode; vanilla ice cream.

Earth Angel’s House-Made Carrot Cake

$8.50
A la mode; vanilla ice cream.

Chocolate Brownie Ice Cream Sundae

$9.50
Vanilla ice cream, caramel walnuts, fresh whipped cream.
  • Order
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs